Stop Hinkley calls for Hinkley Point B to be shut down permanently

23 January 2017

A new report published by Green MSPs in the Scottish Parliament reveals that EDF Energy is asking the Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR) to relax safety standards by doubling the number of cracks allowed in the radioactive cores of ageing reactors like Hinkley Point B.

Prolonged radiation bombardment causes the thousands of graphite bricks that make up reactor cores to crack, threatening a safe shutdown. EDF wants the ONR, to permit an increase in the proportion of cracked bricks from 10 to 20 per cent.

Spokesperson for the Stop Hinkley Campaign, Roy Pumfrey, said: “Hinkley Point B is over 40 years old and well past its sell-by date; its ageing problems are now getting deeply worrying. It is time to shut it down – permanently.”

“EDF is gambling with public safety, but this is a lottery we are not prepared to take part in. Despite the fact that cracks are beginning to appear in the graphite core of these reactors, increasing the risk for us all, we haven’t been asked for once our opinion about extending their life.”

The ONR says the periodic safety review for Hinkley Point B and its sister station in Scotland, Hunterston B, is due at the end of January.

“It is time for the ONR to get a grip and order these reactors to shut down before it’s too late,” said Pumfrey.


Plant Life-Time Extensions for Scotland’s Ageing Reactors the Lack of Public Participation in the Decision-Making Process A report for the Green MSPs by Pete Roche Published January 2017 Click Here

N.B. Virtually everything said about Hunterston B in this report also applies to Hinkley Point B.

See also

More >>>

December 2016:
Hinkley C - not a site for sore eyes:
Once a month, EdeF lay on a visit to the HPC site for the general public. SH member Roy Pumfrey joined the December group.
More >>>



Failing New Nuclear Programme should be Scrapped

17 Feb 2017

The Nuclear Free Local Authorities (NFLA) has called on UK ministers and officials to take stock of the UK’s new nuclear strategy. It is clearly failing to deliver. It is obvious now that it can only be delivered by huge public subsidies. The country can ill afford these at a time when public services are under intense strain. At the same time the ‘Brexit’ decision means the UK is going to leave the EURATOM Treaty which deals another blow to UK nuclear policy For once ministers should look at the area of energy policy that has delivered and will continue to deliver given sensible financial support. This means the creation of a wide renewable energy mix coupled with supporting Councils to deliver decentralised microgeneration projects and fully realising energy storage and energy efficiency technology. Such policies are more cost effective, can be deployed much more swiftly than new nuclear, produce good quality well-paid jobs, deliver low carbon climate change objectives and, above all, would not generate thousands of tonnes of highly radioactive waste.

Toshiba’s announcement that it will not be involved in the construction of new nuclear reactors at the Sellafield ‘Moorside’ development in west Cumbria has thrown into sharp relief the sorry state of the UK’s new nuclear policy. Over the past decade, international energy utilities E-on, RWE Npower, Iberdrola and Centrica have all confidently announced their commitment to building new nuclear power stations, whether at Hinkley Point, Wylfa or Moorside, but then had to pull out as they realise they cannot afford the huge levels of investment that such projects require.

At the same time EDF, who are supposed to be building a new nuclear plant at Hinkley Point, issued three profit warnings last year following a string of unplanned nuclear plant shutdowns. EDF is contending with a government-directed restructuring of the French nuclear industry, and is being pushed by the French state, its controlling shareholder, to rescue reactor builder Areva by taking over the part of its struggling business that is behind EPR technology. The EPR reactor that EDF is building at Flamanville in France is already six years late and €7.2bn over budget. A large drop in French nuclear output over the winter due to safety inspections on 18 of its French reactors, at the request of the country’s nuclear regulator ASN, was partly to blame for a sharp drop in profits. Furthermore, the company is saddled with debt and needs to spend €55bn upgrading its existing reactors in France.

Stop Hinkley spokesperson Roy Pumfrey said: “If you look around the country you find local authorities and communities that are still finding ways to take control of their own energy and make the economic case to install renewables despite cuts in subsidies. This contrasts with the vast level of public subsidy being offered or sought for new nuclear.”

Portsmouth City Council for instance has already has fitted 2MW of roof based solar panels and is planning to carry on installing.

Swindon council launched a series of solar bonds last year. Stanley Town Council teamed up with North Star Solar to offer fuel-poor households the chance to install solar panels, battery storage technology and LED lighting free of charge and independent of government subsidies. Camden Council has teamed up with Islington and Waltham Forest to deliver a pilot programme designed to reduce the fuel bills of residents at risk of fuel poverty.

Pumfrey added: “What we have in Somerset is a large hole in the ground and worsening traffic jams, with no guarantee that it will lead to anything because of the parlous state of the French nuclear industry. The Hinkley Point C site represents a huge missed opportunity. It is time we switched course and got on with the job of making Somerset fit for a low carbon sustainable future.”

More >>>

Stop Hinkley Logo

Page Updated 22-Feb-2017

01 Nov 2016: Nuclear Futures:
Our nuclear power stations are being pushed to run well past their planned life-span. Matthew Hill of BBC Radio 4 asks if this is putting us all in danger. More >>>

Hinkley Point C –
A Tale of Nuclear Dreams!

Some dreams come true; others turn to disaster and turn into nightmares. Hinkley Point C nuclear power station has been a dream to many politicians, is it about to come true?
More >>>

What will be the total cost of nuclear waste?
We won't know until the final bill has been totted up in thousands of years. EdF won't take on that liability. EdF and the UK government are planning to dump it onto future generations.



Click here to obtain stickers

Contact your MP
Add to your favourites





Raymond Briggs
Julie Christie
Terry Jones
Caroline Lucas MP
Jonathon Porritt
Molly Scott Cato MEP
Dame Vivienne Westwood
John Williams